Today I had a great experience that’s been a few months in the making. Last October, one of my newspaper columns was about the 35th anniversary of the date in 1976 when New Albion Brewery, the first modern microbrewery built from scratch, was incorporated by Jack McAuliffe. A homebrewer and beer collector in San Jose, Ed Davis, read my piece in the San Jose Mercury News and contacted me with an intriguing proposal. He had some full bottles of New Albion beer — Ale, Porter and Stout — and did I know anyone who might be interested in them? Obviously, I knew at least one person — me! — and I suggested that it might be fun to open them with Don Barkley, who would been involved in their creation, since he had been the assistant brewer there. Finding a day we were all available took some time, but today Ed and I traveled to Napa to Napa Smith Brewery and met with Don Barkley, who’s now the brewmaster there. But in addition to working at New Albion, Don also founded Mendocino Brewing during his illustrious career, before building and running the new Napa brewery.
Ed told me he’d bought the beers originally at Beltramo’s around 1979 and they’ve been stored in his garage ever since. While they were stored at a slightly higher than cellar temperature, the temperature was relatively consistent and they hadn’t been moved in all that time.
Ed brought one bottle each of Stout, Ale and Porter.
Don Barkley, me and Ed Davis each with a 1979 bottle of New Albion beer, that Ed was kind enough to donate to the cause.
Each of the three beers and their bottles.
Below is a short video (about 14 minutes) of the three of us opening and tasting the three beers.
After the tasting, Don, Napa Smith lead brewer Michael Payne, me and Ed.
In addition to the New Albion beers, Ed also brought a few additional treats, too.
A bottle of DeBakker Porter. DeBakker was a short-lived brewery (1980-82, I believe) that was located in my hometown of Novato, California and was started by a fireman, Tom DeBakker, who had been a homebrewer for about a decade before he opened the brewery.
Ed also brought a run of old Anchor Christmas Ale, 1978, 1980 through 1985, 1991 and 1996.
What a great way to spend a Friday afternoon! I wish all my Fridays could be as enjoyable. The DeBakker porter also held up quite well, it still had a fair amount of carbonation with chocolate notes. The Anchor beers were a mixed bag, some were still terrific, others were past their prime though none were strictly speaking undrinkable. Some of the spicier ones were still showing those spices, though a few of the earlier ones were oxidized, at least a little. The real surprise, of course, was how well the New Albion beers had held up after 33 years. They were bottle-conditioned, which probably helped, but still I expected them to be in worse shape than they were. I think we all thought that, but we were pleasantly surprised. I could stand to be surprised like that more often. Thanks, Ed, for being able to not open those beers for over thirty years and for sharing them with us today. It was like opening and tasting a piece of history.
The Professor says
I’m SO jealous..
Ed Chainey says
Now, with that inspiration, I need to rummage in my basement…
Jean-Pierre says
Watching that makes me pine for a New Albion Porter.
Maureen Ogle says
WOW! Have you sent a link to Jack? Holy cow, what a great story!!!
Cathy McAuliffe-Dickerson says
I will have to show this to Jack tomorrow! He will be tickled pink! Don Barkley, he wants to talk to you!!!
bjornidentity says
So, it really held up Jay?
Cathy, so I’m guessing you are Renee’s sister then? I too have a bottle of aged New Albion Stout, but through Renee, Jack told her to tell me that it probably wasn’t worth opening — to just keep it as a conversation piece.
Now with Jay’s post here, I’m tempted to actually open it… it has been refrigerated all these years — long story.
Hmmm, what to do…
Jay Brooks says
It did, and it wasn’t just me. If you watched the video, you’ll see we all thought so. I wouldn’t make a habit of drinking 30+ year old beer; fresh beer is always desirable. BUt it was very interesting as an experiment to see what time had done to the beer.
bjornidentity says
I just watched the video and… FANTASTIC!
So, what was with the Porter’s cap? Rust?
What year did New Albion change their labels, because the Stout I have has the newer label?
Thanks, Jay!
Renee says
I’m so jealous! Unbelievably special.
beerman49 says
That Ed could hold onto brews for 30+ yrs is remarkable in itself – that he was able to keep them in a cool & dark place is even more remarkable. The conclusion I draw from that video & reinforced by my vertical tastings w/friends of a particular brew (SN Celebration & Bigfoot, Anchor Old Foghorn) & from tasting other “cellared” brews is that those that were high alcohol &/or bottle-conditioned held up better. That those seriously “old fart” beers were still drinkable is amazing – kudos to Don & his boss for bottle-conditioning!
Gregg Hinlicky says
I’ve got a full bottle of the ale What’s it worth?